Conflict between DC's two biggest superheroes didn’t just set box office records when Batman v Superman:  Dawn of Justice opened last weekend (see "’Batman v. Superman’ Posts New March Record"), it also generated the best-selling graphic novel in the book channel in March, according to the Top 20 Adult Fiction Graphic Novel chart provided exclusively to ICv2 by Nielsen BookScan.  Batman vs. Superman: The Greatest Battles, a collection of classic stories starring the two characters, was released in December, first charted in February (at #6), and took the #1 slot in March.

There was no aura of success for DC affecting the rest of its line, however; DC’s classic Batman: The Killing Joke Dlx. Ed. HC was the only other DC Comics title in the Top 20, staying in the top five at #4.

Marvel Comics placed four titles in the Top 20, two Deadpool titles, still supported by the continuing success of the movie, and two Wars titles.  It’s interesting that the film-fueled sales of the 2007 volume Civil War outsold the collection of Marvel’s huge just-completed editorial event, Secret Wars; Civil War was #6, and Secret Wars was #17.

VIZ Media had another big month, representing for the manga category with nine volumes in the Top 20.  One-Punch Man, at #2, was the top manga title.  New manga hits outnumbered old, with two One-Punch Man volumes and five Tokyo Ghoul volumes in the Top 20, plus one Yu-Gi-Oh! Zexal and one Naruto volume.

The Walking Dead compendium volumes are now clearly outselling every other format of the graphic novels.  All three placed in the Top 20 in March, as the TV season continued its second-half run.

The latest Plants vs. Zombies volume from Dark Horse Comics moved up between its first and second months of sales; placing at #7 in February and #5 in March.

And the new Dan Clowes graphic novel Patience, which Fantagraphics Books is giving a lot of support, debuted at #15.

BookScan Top 20 Graphic Novels in March 2016

Rank

Title

Author

Publisher

1

BATMAN VS. SUPERMAN: THE GREASTEST BATTLES

VARIOUS

DC COMICS

2

ONE-PUNCH MAN VOL. 5

ONE

VIZ MEDIA

3

THE WALKING DEAD COMPENDIUM VOL. 3

ROBERT KIRKMAN

IMAGE COMICS

4

BATMAN: THE KILLING JOKE DLX ED

ALAN MOORE

DC COMICS

5

PLANTS VS. ZOMBIES VOL 4: GARDEN WARFARE HC

PAUL TOBIN

DARK HORSE COMICS

6

CIVIL WAR

MARK MILLAR

MARVEL COMICS

7

THE WALKING DEAD COMPENDIUM VOL. 1

ROBERT KIRKMAN

IMAGE COMICS

8

TOKYO GHOUL VOL. 5

SUI ISHIDA

VIZ MEDIA

9

TOKYO GHOUL VOL. 1

SUI ISHIDA

VIZ MEDIA

10

YU-GI-OH! ZEXAL VOL. 8

SHIN YOSHIDA

VIZ MEDIA

11

DEADPOOL KILLS THE MARVEL UNIVERSE

CULLEN BUNN

MARVEL COMICS

12

DEADPOOL BY DANIEL WAY: THE COMPLETE COLLECTION VOL. 1

DANIEL WAY

MARVEL COMICS

13

THE WALKING DEAD COMPENDIUM VOL. 2

ROBERT KIRKMAN

IMAGE COMICS

14

ONE-PUNCH MAN VOL. 1

ONE

VIZ MEDIA

15

PATIENCE HC

DANIEL CLOWES

FANTAGRAPHICS BOOKS

16

TOKYO GHOUL VOL. 2

SUI ISHIDA

VIZ MEDIA

17

SECRET WARS HC

JONATHAN HICKMAN

MARVEL COMICS

18

NARUTO: THE SEVENTH HOKAGE & THE SCARLET SPRING

MASASHI KISHIMOTO

VIZ MEDIA

19

TOKYO GHOUL VOL. 4

SUI ISHIDA

VIZ MEDIA

20

TOKYO GHOUL VOL. 3

SUI ISHIDA

VIZ MEDIA

For past BookScan Top 20 Graphic Novel lists, see the "BookScan Top 20 GN Index."