A new "academic" study Doctor Who and Race, which includes essays from "publish or perish" types from around the globe, claims that the venerable BBC science fiction series is "thunderously racist." Among the evidence brought forth in this collection of academic essays that is due to be published in July is an "inappropriately slapstick" take on Hitler in a 2011 episode, the failure to cast an Asian or a black actor in the series’ lead role, and the use of white actors in non-white roles in some vintage Whovian sagas such as "The Talons of Weng-Chiang" from 1977.
One writer even finds fault with the Fifth Doctor Peter Davison’s obsession with cricket, which American academic Amit Gupta claims harkens back to the "racial and class nostalgia of the British Empire." Toss in what the authors describe as the portrayal of people from primitive cultures as "savages," and Australian academic Lindy Orthia, who compiled the collection, arrives at the conclusion "The biggest elephant in the room is the problem privately nursed by many fans of loving a TV show when it is thunderously racist."
According to the Radio Times, the BBC has defended the series by pointing to "a strong record of diverse casting among both the regular and guest cast." The BBC specifically pointed to Freema Agyeman’s casting as the Time Lord’s companion in 2007 and Noel Clarke’s recurring role as Mickey Smith. The BBC did not specifically respond to the fact that there has, so far at least, still not been a black or Asian Doctor.
New Book Claims Series Is 'Thunderously Racist'
Posted by ICv2 on May 30, 2013 @ 2:56 pm CT
MORE COMICS
Column by Rob Salkowitz
December 23, 2024
We may be ending the year with more questions than answers, but here are five major trends that helped shape the business this year.
Third Crossover Miniseries by Benjamin Percy will Launch in April
December 23, 2024
Following crossovers with Wolverine and Black Panther, this is the third miniseries by writer Benjamin Percy featuring a Predator invading the Marvel Universe.
MORE NEWS
Showbiz Round-up
December 23, 2024
There’s no slowdown in Hollywood news as we approach the holiday break, and we round it up here.
Of Space Ghost and Jonny Quest
December 22, 2024
Dynamite Entertainment will release a comic crossover of two Hanna-Barbera properties: Space Ghost and Jonny Quest.