Heritage Auctions dropped the hammer on a high-grade Batman #1 at a record-setting amount of $2.2 million at their January 14 Comics & Comic Art Signature Auction in Dallas, Texas.
The uptrend in the high-end collectible comics market rolls on as the finest-known Batman #1 (see "Finest-Known 'Batman #1' Hits the Auction Block in January") yielded a record-setting number for a comic starring Bruce Wayne as the caped-crusader. The final price on the comic, including a buyer's fee, was $2,220,000. This is $720,000 more than the Detective Comics #27 sold in November (see "Breaking News: Hammer Drops on 'Detective Comics' #27 at a Record $1.5 million"), and more than double the 2012 sale of a CGC 9.2 Batman #1 sold in 2012 (see "'Batman' #1 Sells for $850K").
Other notable sales on the first day of this auction were a CGC 8.5 Captain America Comics #1 that sold for $384,000, a CGC 9.2 Fantastic Four #5 that went for $72,000, and a CGC 9.2 Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles #1, signed by Kevin Eastman, that went for $28,800. It should also be noted that the Captain America Comics #1 sold for $530,000 less than a CGC 9.4 copy in 2019 (see "'Captain America' #1 Gets Record Price at Heritage Auction"). This is significant because the CGC 8.5 copy is still a rare book (only nine copies known in grade CGC 8.5 or higher), yet it failed to command a similar price premium of the CGC 9.0 or above copies. This also indicates that there is essentially a 140% premium gap between a CGC 8.5 graded copy and a CGC 9.4 graded copy, despite the generally low overall population of this book in higher grades.
New Heritage Auction Sales Were Also Recorded for High-Grade 'Captain America Comics' #1, Fantastic Four' #5, and 'TMNT' #1
Posted by Jeffrey Dohm-Sanchez on January 14, 2021 @ 3:06 pm CT