Column by Paul Levitz
Posted by Paul Levitz on February 29, 2016 @ 11:40 pm CT
Which brings to mind how graphic novels are retailed in comic shops. There’s a wide variety of display approaches: everything from purely spine out alphabetical to dedicated sections with full facings for favorite talents like Neil Gaiman or Alan Moore. Every shop has to figure out its own dynamics, of course, but a couple of thoughts come to mind:
First, we remain in the pattern that there are certain graphic novels which are clearly "gateway drugs." Ever since the beginnings of the graphic novel as a viable format in America, three decades ago, we’ve seen certain titles create new regular readers. Retailers would even offer hesitant customers a "try it, and if you don’t like it, I’ll give you your money back" deals. At the beginning, it was challenging because someone would wander in having heard of The Dark Knight Returns or Watchmen, and after the first taste there weren’t easy next choices to offer. But now, there’s a wide range of selections.
To best take advantage of this, perhaps a "start here" section is in order? A small section of full facing graphic novels that are proven gateway drugs, stocked perpetually with handselling instructions to the team to steer unfamiliar faces towards them? Experience with college students has taught me that many of your newer customers had their first exposure to graphic novels in a classroom, unsurprisingly with a list of titles headed by Maus, yet Art Spiegelman’s masterpiece is rarely displayed prominently in comic shops. And right now there’s no creator reaching more new readers than Raina Telgemeier. Old reliable gateways like Sandman belong on that rack as well, along with a titles tied to successful current film and television adaptations from comics.
There’s also the classic indie bookstore approach of having a “staff picks” section, with cute little handwritten cards pitching each chosen title. Comic shop staffers are exceptionally committed to the form, and can be very passionate in steering folks, but not everyone who wanders into a store speaks up, or is noticed if they come in at a busy time. This approach is perfect for the more introverted browser.
Finally, bear in mind that the large number of graphic novel only customers (as distinct from our vital and passionate core customers who scoop up periodicals, graphic novels and other categories) tend to shop less frequently than the Wednesday regulars. That argues for a section displaying the more interesting new graphic novels full facing for a longer time, perhaps a full month at least. Define "interesting" as you choose, but don’t expect the one or two graphic novel a month customer to be able to find the tree they don’t yet know they want in a forest of spines. At the very least, maybe a “New this month” list posted on the endcap of a spine-out section, with covers next to the titles and some basic info to invite discovery?
The good news is that word of mouth is a stronger sales tool than ever in the era of social media, but the bad news is that it’s not as favorable for the brick & mortar retailer as the online seller, since online can capture the impulse buy instantly. The advantage the physical store has is discovery, the joyful process of searching for what interests you. Research has proven that in many circumstances, humans get a bigger kick pursuing things than achieving them. Browsing in a comic shop or bookstore is a delight for many of us, but good retail practices can make it more likely to lead to unexpected sales.
--Paul Levitz has been active as a comic fan (The Comic Reader), editor (Batman), writer (Legion of Super-Heroes), executive (30 years at DC Comics, ending as President & Publisher), historian (75 Years of DC Comics: The Art of Modern Myth-Making), and educator.
--The opinions expressed in this column are solely those of the writer, and do not necessarily reflect the views of the editorial staff of ICv2.com.