The cards were stolen from the Indianapolis Convention Center vendor storage area on August 2, 2023, prior to the opening of the show, and the product stolen was primarily Commander Masters sealed cases (see "'Magic: The Gathering' Grand Theft at Gen Con 2023"). The two individuals who are persons of interest in this case are Thomas Dunbar and Andrew Pearson Giaume, aka Pearson Giaume (see Twitter post below for pictures). Both suspects reside in New York City, and are being sought by IMPD for questioning. Anyone with any information on their whereabouts should call Crime Stoppers at 317-262-8477.

Both Reside in New York City
Posted by Jeffrey Dohm-Sanchez on August 11, 2023 @ 7:40 am CT

The Indianapolis Metro Police Department has requested the public's assistance in finding two men who have been identified as persons of interest in the theft of $300,000 worth of Magic: The Gathering cards from Gen Con 2023.
IMPD Detectives would like to speak with: Thomas J Dunbar and Andrew Pearson Giaume, regarding the theft of $300,000 worth of “Magic: The Gathering” gaming cards from Gen Con Indy 2023. Both are residents of New York City.
— IMPD (@IMPDnews) August 10, 2023
Call Crime Stoppers at 317-262-8477.
Case# IP230075163 https://t.co/XeaVm5zPFx pic.twitter.com/BJR4QZzfSM
MORE GAMES
Board Game Set in the Golden Age of Hollywood by Devir Games
July 18, 2025
Devir Games will release Red Carpet , a new board game, at Gen Con 2025 and then, later into retail.
'Whiskerwing' and 'The Cinderfin'
July 18, 2025
Arcane Tinmen will release new Dragon Shield: Spirit Animal accessories into retail.
MORE NEWS
Debuting Absolute Catwoman and More New Characters
July 18, 2025
The event will deepen the storytelling of the Absolute Universe and bring in new characters, including the first appearance of Absolute Catwoman.
New Bag-Building Train Game Heads to Retail
July 18, 2025
Dire Wolf Digital will release Lightning Train , a new bag-building train game, into retail.