Column by Rob Salkowitz
Posted by Rob Salkowitz on March 20, 2023 @ 6:29 pm CT
UGC on the Rise. One big 2022 trend that is coming soon to a screen near you is the rise of user-generated content (UGC). For those of you keeping score, it made my "trends to watch" list each of the past two years, and it might, finally be worth watching. UGC has always been a popular model with the Asian platforms like WEBTOON and Tapas, to the point that Tapas abandoned its original editorial content last summer and just recently shuttered its South Korean operations to focus exclusively, one presumes, on commercializing the UGC model here in the U.S.
Korean Webtoon Creation Tool"). Rather than positioning itself as a content player, Toonit is more about being a tool-kit for storytellers. The company compares itself to Canva and Figma, collaborative tools for designing user experiences for other apps and technology.
The company’s flagship product is Toonit Studio, a 3D-based tool designed to streamline the art and design aspects of comics storytelling. According to the company, Toonit Studio offers the ability to drag and drop visual components like characters, backgrounds, text and effects into a storyboard interface. "What requires professional artists weeks or even months to draw a single chapter, can now be automated in minutes," said the company in its press release.
Toonit’s theory of the case is that the stories themselves are more important than the artwork, which is just a commodity that can be easily replaced by templated processes. As someone who enjoys and appreciates comic art drawn by actual human beings, I don’t relish the prospect of reading the output of this product for pleasure. However, I see the value for people or businesses who need to put out comics-style content in a hurry and don’t know the first thing about what they are doing.
IDW Publishing Loses $335,000 in Fiscal Q1") is an interesting tidbit that the company is trying to expand its digital footprint in a couple of different directions, because why not?
IDW is moving to a Shopify-based store for its digital content, no surprise as Shopify is rapidly becoming the standard for this kind of ecommerce. It is also trying to generate more buzz and engagement around its titles with more interactive features, including motion comics and user-generated content, according to the announcement. How UGC would work in the context of an established publisher like IDW remains to be seen, especially one like IDW that has relied so heavily on licensed content.
One can imagine a model that allows fans to create officially-sanctioned fan-fiction around corporate-owned IP. In fact, I’ve been personally involved in a few ventures of this nature over the past couple of years that have, for various reasons, amounted to nothing. It’s hard to say if that is what IDW has in mind, or whether it’s more of a WEBTOON/Tapas-type play. If it is the former, it remains an intriguing prospect, though one that is difficult to get off the ground.
More comics on more screens. IDW’s announcement also mentioned an expansion of plain old digital publishing, with plans to offer digital versions of its titles through the new Shopify portal. That’s yet another announcement of motion on the digital comics front, which has been mostly quiet for years since Amazon’s comiXology acquisition extinguished realistic hopes of competition.
Now that comiXology, if not the entire digital comics market, appears to be of little interest to Amazon (see "Bloodbath at comiXology"), we’re seeing a bunch of startups scrambling out of the shadows to take advantage of a generational opportunity to get into the game.
Both of these platforms are hoping to "rekindle" the promise of digital sales eventually rising beyond its historical non-pandemic ceiling of 10-15% of the market, combining the usual value proposition of digital comics (convenience, immediacy, binge-ability, discoverability and never worrying about comics being out of stock) with attractive subscription plans and other fun features.
In Digital Comics Space, Global Comix Offers Signs of Life"), and both companies seem to understand that growing the comics pie through whatever means helps everyone in the end.
Too little, too late? It’s encouraging to see innovation in the comics space despite all the dark clouds hanging over tech and media right now. The long game for all these companies is to jumpstart the creation of new comics IP to capture the imagination of fans, bring new talent into the industry, and create new ways for those outside the hobby to find their way in. Whatever you may think of the individual ideas behind these companies, the impulse is admirable.
Original Art, GoFundMe to Benefit Fat Jack’s"). Having lost my longtime Seattle local, Comics Dungeon, during the pandemic, it was bittersweet to paw through the bins and shelves where I first discovered my lifelong love of comics, and to hear that things are not going great with the fundraising efforts.
Whatever promise the high-tech future of comics may hold, I very much hope there is still room in that future for the industry and the artform’s glorious past.
The opinions expressed in this column are solely those of the writer, and do not necessarily reflect the views of the editorial staff of ICv2.com.
Rob Salkowitz (@robsalk) is the author of Comic-Con and the Business of Pop Culture.